1. barbara
    barbara September 24, 2017 at 1:05 pm | | Reply

    What a winning person who’s lived purposefully and happily. Great stories herein. I’lll take me the image of his chasing just born pigs while a sheep is giving birth just over the fence to triplets! Later on he added in the same evening he had a chimney fire. No wonder he drank……

  2. Jill
    Jill September 24, 2017 at 1:33 pm | | Reply

    What a remarkable life and story of a life. Thank you Peter and Erica. There is something of the very essence of Vermont in this program. Right down to granite.

  3. Rip Rybnikar
    Rip Rybnikar September 24, 2017 at 1:51 pm | | Reply

    Hill Farm reminded me of my mother’s family. Please forgive the digression. At the start of the 20th century my great-grandfather’s farm was celebrated locally. But after World War II my maternal grandparents lost the Cabot farm about the time I was born in 1952. My grandfather felt it was his fault and never recovered from the depression that followed. He worked at the Cabot creamery for several years until they moved south to become caretakers for an estate in northwestern Connecticut. My mother’s suicide in 1964 finished off my grandfather. My grandmother had been a farm wife at 15. She soldiered on for another 18 years trying to support me and my brother as best she could. There is a book in how poor people from the north country were treated by those who hired them for next to nothing and a room.

  4. Sage Kennedy
    Sage Kennedy September 24, 2017 at 6:52 pm | | Reply

    “I never was much of a cooperator.”

    This was beautiful. Thank you for sharing Peter with us. I will be sure to watch the documentary.

  5. EAH
    EAH September 24, 2017 at 7:44 pm | | Reply

    Powerful stuff. I am afraid that he is correct that the days of subsistence farming and the ability of fiercely independent folks who wanted to live quietly but self reliantly on treasured farms are increasingly emperiled.
    I got to Vermont in 1959 and as nearly as I could tell, nearly every town had several such farms. The saying that Vermont was the “Last Stronghold of the Yankees” seemed quite correct.
    I was in health care and as I remember almost every week brought such people who came the the hospital for some long standing problem that finally got the best of them – for a while at least. I admitted such a patient who lived on a remote hill farm. He had lived in the barn with the animals since November and arrived for care in April or May. He was a bit of a mess on arrival and the ever loving nursing staff of the Mary Fletcher Hospital took him into the shower and cleaned him up – even putting some Evening in Paris in his hair, and sent him back to me a transformed character. He arrived to the hospital exactly at dinner time, and on telling him that I would be to see him after dinner, he said: “You don’t need to feed me because I haven’t done my chores yet”.

    Mr Dunning is clearly more sophisticated than my patient but they are both cut out of the same indomitable, rough cloth. I guess it is inevitable that these characters are nearly gone for the reasons P. Dunning articulated, but Vermont seems a bit less authentic as they disappear.

  6. Yney
    Yney September 24, 2017 at 11:25 pm | | Reply

    What a touching bittersweet story , thanks for sharing it . It almost brought me to tears to see all the knowledge farmers trades people have and that we are not passing on to the next generation , I am from Honduras and this story just brought back my grandmother’s memories and all the herbal and sewing knowledge she had that I will never learned .
    Thank you so much for showing us that even flawed humans as we are , we have something worth sharing and appreciating .

  7. Bess O'Brien
    Bess O'Brien October 8, 2017 at 12:08 pm | | Reply

    Powerful story about how hard it is to let go of the farm. The love and hate of it all. We hope that younger farmers who are now doing organic farming will maybe take these old geezers place. We hope. Great job Erica.

  8. Andrew Dunning McGreer
    Andrew Dunning McGreer October 15, 2017 at 6:25 pm | | Reply

    I remember as a young teenager working on the farm with Peter. Uncle Peter was tireless, so driven and even though in the beginning I hated it because I was used to hanging out with my friend, by day three I was hooked. I learned so much about life, hard work and it provided me with a work ethic that others can’t match except of course for Peter. Thank you Peter for the amazing life lessons, love you buddy!

  9. Doug W.
    Doug W. November 6, 2017 at 8:22 pm | | Reply

    Erica and Peter, thank you both. So reminiscent of the photographic work of John Miller and Richard Brown documenting hill farms and their residents. Will definitely try to watch the movie. High land prices in Vt. make it next to impossible to subsistence farm these days. It may still be possible in more remote, less expensive corners of the northern border region, but supporting communities and know-how are disappearing too.

  10. coleen
    coleen November 8, 2017 at 3:51 pm | | Reply

    I LOVED this episode and the movie even more so. The collision of beauty and heartbreak, we can all relate.

  11. connie
    connie November 13, 2017 at 2:09 am | | Reply

    As a solo woman farmer, his video made me feel less crazy & weird, less dramatic and angry…. all while feeling even more reverence about the world. At 56 Im starting to consider how to extricate myself from this life now. Still not sure how to, but will some day. It really is a daily “collision of beauty and heartbreak”. I hope he has a restful life soon, he deserves it. He’s earned it.

  12. Kimberly Ray
    Kimberly Ray January 6, 2018 at 3:31 pm | | Reply

    Peter , I feel your pain, I am a fifth year old homosaipen, who doesn’t relish the fact of Gettn old , your story didn’t help , except to confirm my forth coming future. But I hope this finds you healthy @ happier . Kim -n-Carolina

  13. Moshe Braner
    Moshe Braner January 25, 2018 at 1:40 pm | | Reply

    The film “Peter and the Farm” is now available on Netflix Streaming.

  14. Heather Kennedy
    Heather Kennedy March 8, 2018 at 2:55 pm | | Reply

    Anybody know where the sheep went? I’ve been wanting to get a pair of Clun Forests………….

  15. Cathy Tayes
    Cathy Tayes June 21, 2018 at 7:28 am | | Reply

    Such an impressive man. Been through so much yet never allowed himself to become a victim of his circumstances – he just keeps chipping away at keeping his farm going,no matter what. As someone else noted – a bitter-sweet documentary. May you find love, happiness and most of all, peace of mind.

  16. coleen keiser
    coleen keiser June 8, 2019 at 10:30 am | | Reply

    How is Peter? He is unforgettable.

  17. Coleen Keiser
    Coleen Keiser October 9, 2021 at 10:58 pm | | Reply

    Springfield Reporter, The (VT) – Tuesday, July 31, 2018

    Peter Dunning, a farmer, poet, and artist, has passed away at the age of 73 on Wednesday, July 4.

    He was born August 8, 1944 in New York City and was five years old when his mother died. After spending several years in orphanages and foster homes, he was adopted by the Dunning family in 1952 and moved to their home in New Jersey, and later to a dairy farm in New Hampshire.

    As a young man, he served in the Marine Corps for several years, based in Waikiki, Hawaii. He went on to attend the University of Connecticut, graduating with a degree in art. In 1978, he and his second wife, Joan Dunning, purchased Mile Hill Farm in Springfield, which he tended devotedly for the next 40 years. The purebred Guernsey cows he raised were the direct descendants of his father’s herd, at one time the largest in New Hampshire. His relationship with his land and animals was the subject of a documentary film, “Peter and the Farm,” in 2016.

    He died naturally, peacefully, and surrounded by family at the farm. In accordance with his wishes, he was buried in the orchard that afternoon.
    Springfield Reporter, The (VT) – Tuesday, July 31, 2018

    1. Grace Stoeckle
      Grace Stoeckle November 9, 2021 at 9:19 am | | Reply

      Thank you for this update. I have been searching.

Leave a Reply

The maximum upload file size: 2 MB. You can upload: image, audio, video, document, spreadsheet. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here


Get the Newsletter

I'll email you when new episodes arrive.

Get the show

Never miss an episode! Subscribe to have the show downloaded to your device:
the iTunes store

Follow me

Extras, chatter, and other observations (and show notices, of course):


  • Spoon Agave commented on What Class are You?: This must be one of the most important topics (...)
  • Dave commented on What Class are You?: Erica, I loved your show about class. It chal (...)
  • grace commented on What Class are You?: LOVE this....please, continue forever.... You (...)
  • Jennifer Gennari commented on What Class are You?: Loved this. Good for me to hear. I’m one of t (...)
  • erica commented on What Class are You?: Coming soon! (...)